What You Should Know Before Buying Self Storage Insurance

January 16, 2023 Reading Time: 5 minutes
Home » Everything Storage

The word “insurance” immediately strikes up thoughts of cars and houses as well as less tangible but infinitely more important things like health and life. But don’t forget about the items in your life that you care about. Putting something like furniture, clothes or appliances in self storage doesn’t signify a lack of care for them, but rather the commitment to continue keeping and caring for them in the future. Self storage insurance is just the next logical step! However, there are things you should know before signing on the dotted line.

To navigate this important step, we’ve reached out to Bill Howe, manager at Yardi’s Risk Management Solutions department and specifically the GoodShield Storage Protection division. GoodShield offers protection for self storage tenants against damage or loss of stored belongings due to fire, smoke, lightning, wind, water damage and theft.

Many questions regarding self storage insurance are answered with “first check the details of your policy.” Policies can vary by insurance company, and legal definitions can vary by state, so it’s often hard to give universal answers to some questions. But what are some of the universal things people should avoid when shopping for storage insurance, regardless of company or state?

Avoid any coverage that sounds too good to be true. This is a basic rule in insurance, especially when it covers multiple subjects like commercial fleet insurance and self-storage insurance. Also avoid large coverage amounts with minimal premiums, policies that do not cover theft, or coverage that is not enough to cover ALL of what you have stored. Do not accept a policy that doesn’t offer “Replacement Cost” (RC) instead of “Actual Cash Value” (ACV) coverage.

Homeowner’s or renter’s insurance can cover some stored items up to a certain percentage. Is this enough for most storage users?

This depends on the total value of the items in storage. Most renter’s policies traditionally provide 10% of the policy’s total limit for contents/personal belongings off premises. So, if a policy has a contents coverage amount of $10k, any loss to items off-premises from the covered dwelling would only be covered up to $1,000. However, many policies specifically exclude items that are stored in a professional storage facility. So always check your policy and speak with your agent / representative to make sure your policy will cover these items.

framed paintings stored on shelf

Many storage facilities offer their own storage insurance. Is it usually better to go with this option or to go with a third party?

Storage facilities that offer their own coverage are an easy and convenient way to cover your stored items. However, this also always depends on the company that actually underwrites the insurance. Just be sure that the coverage offered is from a reputable insurer. In addition, it can be very difficult to obtain third party coverage specifically and only for stored items without purchasing an Inland Marine policy, which tends to be more expensive.

Some self storage users live in areas with high risks of earthquakes, floods, hurricanes, wildfires and so on. What should they expect when looking for storage insurance?

Earthquake is usually an excluded peril on these policies. However, it is available in high-risk areas. Flood coverage is also usually available, and wind is usually a standard covered peril. Policies usually cover fire, regardless of the source. In some areas, you can add additional endorsements to cover some of these items. It very much depends on the location.

Can you tell us a bit about the specifics of vehicle storage insurance and how it applies to vehicles that are declared legally off the road?

This all depends on the policy; some policies specifically exclude motorized vehicles. This is truly a case of checking the policy to make sure those items are covered and not excluded.

boats in indoor storage

What advice do you have for those who need to store more valuable items, like jewelry or art? How often does the renter need to contact an evaluator when insuring such items?

Owners need to cover items such as these under an endorsement to a homeowners or renters policy; storage insurance will have small limits for these items if any coverage at all. There may be limits as to what, and how much, you can add to this coverage. There are also stand-alone policies in the marketplace that are available specifically for these items. Usually this will be via an Inland Marine policy. Also, this will almost always require recent professional appraisals for all “high-risk” (high-theft/high-value) items.

A quick scenario: A storage user fails to pay rent on their unit for several months, and the facility, after exhausting all legal recourse, decides to auction off or otherwise dispose of the contents of said unit. The items are still covered by a third party insurance policy, which the user still pays. What happens?

This is a very tricky question. Since the user is under contract and the owner / operator has the legal recourse to sell or dispose of the property, coverage will not come into play for these items. Also, the user would NOT be able to claim the items as lost or damaged. The policy in place would essentially be void due to a breach of contract with the owner/operator.

Can you tell us a little more about GoodShield and what it does differently from other insurance policies?

The most important differentiator between GoodShield and other programs is our proprietary integration within the facility management software platform. This greatly reduces the work for the on-site storage staff and provides immediate turnkey coverage for renters. The advantage is smooth, “hands-off” policy integration and management, as the system does most of the work. In addition, all renters are pre-approved and there are no underwriting questions or credit checks. The claims process is also streamlined and faster. All of this makes the program exceptionally convenient for both the renters and the on-site facility users.

person closing a blue self storage unit gate with their foot

If you’re currently looking for a self storage unit, be sure to check out storage facilities near you and use the included contact number to get all the details related to insurance and amenities.

The goal of any insurance policy is to make the unexpected a little less so, no matter what you insure. Take the time to research policies carefully and make sure you know the true value of your belongings and the storage unit size you need. Songwriters and poets love saying “you never know what you have until it’s gone” but good storage insurance says otherwise!

Related posts

How to Store a Boat in Self Storage: Types, Costs & What to Look For

By Maria Gatea | July 1, 2026

Storing a boat in self storage comes down to four decisions: how far the facility is from your launch point, what type of storage suits your climate (outdoor, covered, or indoor), how to prepare the boat before storing it, and whether the facility’s security and access hours fit how you use your boat. First-time owners who think through these factors before signing a lease tend to get significantly more use out of their boat.

Best RV Destinations in the U.S. (2026): Oceanfront Drives Beat America’s Usual RV Favorites

By Andrei Popa | June 30, 2026

A new kind of traveler is reshaping the RV campground: younger, plugged in and rarely fully off the clock.

Temporary Storage During Emergencies: What to Know Before You Need It

By Maria Gatea | June 30, 2026

When a hurricane’s bearing down, a wildfire is closing in, or floodwater has already reached your front door, the last thing you want to be doing is figuring out where to put your stuff – but that’s exactly when people find themselves scrambling for temporary storage.

Where to Donate Furniture in NYC (With Free Pick-Up Options)

By Maria Gatea | June 24, 2026

Finding somewhere to donate furniture in NYC is more complicated than it should be. Not every organization accepts large items, pick-up availability is inconsistent, and the options that do exist aren’t always easy to find in one place. If you’re specifically hoping to donate furniture with free pick-up, the list of options gets even shorter.

Clean Out, Give Back: Where to Donate Clothes in Los Angeles

By Anca Lenta | June 23, 2026

Few cities reinvent themselves like Los Angeles, and wardrobes tend to follow suit. Between changing seasons, evolving trends and an endless calendar of occasions worth dressing for, closets fill up fast, making the question of where to donate clothes in Los Angeles one that most Angelenos eventually find themselves asking.

How to Store Shoes Based on Your Personality

By Anca Lenta | June 23, 2026

Your shoe closet is lying — not about how many pairs you own (that number is likely higher than you’d admit), but about who you are. The way you approach shoe storage, or avoid it, is one of the more honest reflections of your personality that exists in a home.

Tiny Home Storage Ideas for Every Nook and Cranny

By Anca Lenta | June 23, 2026

Tiny home storage is one of those challenges that sounds straightforward until you’re standing in 200 square feet wondering where the winter coats are supposed to go. You didn’t downsize for the storage anxiety — you did it for the coziest place you’ve ever called home, a wallet that finally feels lighter, and a minimalist lifestyle that suits you just fine.

Best States for Electric Vehicles (2026): The West Leads EV Adoption, Oklahoma Speeds Up

By Andrei Popa | June 22, 2026

Last updated: June 22, 2026.

Self Storage Discounts: Types, Tips and How to Get the Best Deals for Your Needs

By Maria Gatea | June 17, 2026

When you start looking for a self storage unit to rent, one thing becomes clear very quickly: self storage discounts are a standard part of the industry. From introductory specials to military savings and online-only rates, operators frequently offer promotions designed to make renting a unit more affordable and flexible.