Extra Space Storage - 8840 East 42nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46226

4.8/5 - 386 Reviews
Location:
8840 East 42nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46226
Office hours:
  • Mon-Fri: 9:30 a.m. - 6 p.m.
  • Sat: 9 a.m. - 5:30 p.m.

Extra Space Storage - 8840 East 42nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46226

  • Climate-Controlled

    Protect belongings from temperature changes and humidity

  • Indoor

    Units are located indoors for added protection and convenience

  • Drive-Up Access

    Drive directly up to your unit for easy loading and unloading

    Not sure which size you need? Check our size guide to find the perfect fit.
    8x10 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    $70/mo
    8x10 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $54/mo
    5x15 Self Storage 75 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $90/mo
    5x15 Self Storage 75 Sq. Ft.
    $63/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $61/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    $47/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $39/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $36/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    $27/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $23/mo
    4x8 Self Storage 32 Sq. Ft.
    $73/mo
    16x10 Self Storage 160 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $125/mo
    10x16 Self Storage 160 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $125/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $131/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    $125 - $156/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $114/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $122/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    $74 - $112/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $58 - $83/mo
    8x20 Self Storage 160 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $125/mo
    8x20 Vehicle 160 Sq. Ft.
    Car Storage Parking
    $122/mo
    8x15 Self Storage 120 Sq. Ft.
    $104/mo
    5x20 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $122/mo
    20x15 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $293/mo
    20x10 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    $185/mo
    15x30 Vehicle 450 Sq. Ft.
    Drive-up Access Parking RV Storage
    $359/mo
    15x15 Self Storage 225 Sq. Ft.
    $201/mo
    10x30 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $301/mo
    10x30 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $293/mo
    10x30 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    $260/mo
    10x30 Vehicle 300 Sq. Ft.
    Drive-up Access Parking RV Storage
    $260/mo
    10x25 Vehicle 250 Sq. Ft.
    Drive-up Access Parking RV Storage
    $225/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $219/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $197/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    $185/mo
    10x20 Vehicle 200 Sq. Ft.
    Car Storage Drive-up Access Parking
    $185/mo
    8x30 Self Storage 240 Sq. Ft.
    $217/mo
    No units are currently available.

    Amenities & features

    • Climate-Controlled
    • Indoor
    • Drive-Up Access
    • Retail Available
    • Onsite Manager
    • Contactless Renting
    • Security Camera
    • Gate
    • Parking
    • Enclosed
    • Elevators
    • Multi-Level Storage
    • Online Payment
    • RV Storage

    Customer reviews

    4.8/5
    Average rating
    386
    Number of reviews

    Read some helpful reviews of Extra Space Storage, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

    We were greeted immediately and asked what our needs were. We were taken to a unit that we thought might suit our needs. Once we decided, the contract was drawn up quickly and we were on our way. When we got to the unit, the gentleman that took care of us brought me a cart and asked if we need anything else. Very good experience. ... Read more
    Mike G. - 3 June 2026
    Miracles E. - 1 March 2026
    Alisha was fantastic from the very beginning to the very end. She was more than willing to show me multiple units without hesitation, and even answered all my what I'm sure were silly questions with a smile! Thank you! ... Read more
    Josh B. - 28 February 2026
    The staff was very generous, helpful, and friendly. I look forward to keeping my items in their units and doing business with them in the future. The building is very secure with great affordable prices for your money's worth! ... Read more
    John B. - 18 December 2025
    A few weeks ago, I rented a storage unit from Extra Space Storage, and I was truly blessed to have Fabian assist me through the process. In today’s world, genuine customer service is rare—but Fabian is a gem! She is naturally pleasant, incredibly helpful, and clearly dedicated to her work. I’m giving the highest possible rating because she is worth every single ?? ... Read more
    Rochelle H. - 19 September 2025
    Whats the point of renting a drive up storage place if you can never drive up to it due to people parking and blocking your unit. Also theres a mice problem check out this gift ?? i have to trash majority of my things ... Read more
    Samara R. - 18 September 2025
    D K. - 17 September 2025
    Samara R. - 30 August 2025
    Rent for a 10'x10' went from ~$60 a month to $100 without warning or communication of the increase. Spoke to a rep with this company and I was told that "Extra Space Storage can/will change your rent whenever the market reflects a need to increase"...basically saying that they will charge whatever they feel like and it's up to me to pay to find a new location. Be warned that this company also doesn't cover theft if their employees rob your unit. Happened to my parents at a different location and the company said tough luck. Went through insurance to cover what was stolen but extra space was obstinate through the entire process. ... Read more
    Ryan B. - 30 July 2025
    So appreciative of the patience Alysha and Leroy showed me today. I lost my keys; and they went above and beyond to get the old lock removed and get me a new one. The atmosphere is welcoming, and so clean!!! If you want people that care, will make you laugh, and get the job done this is the storage place for you! ... Read more
    Margret S. - 14 June 2025
    China S. - 14 June 2025
    Alysha was very helpful today 4/29 As soon as we walked in she greeted us with a big smile and positive attitude. Walked us to the storage units and helped us decide which was more convenient for us! So glad we stopped in today! ... Read more
    Jazlyn J. - 29 April 2025
    Paul S. - 28 February 2025
    Tyler goes above and beyond each time. Thank you ! Update- All managers are always so helpful and knowledgeable. They can’t control rates or increases but they always ensure you get the best deal for your needs. I’ve enjoyed both the unit and office spaces and will always go to Extra Space for my storage needs ... Read more
    Ty'Azsha R. - 27 February 2025
    Had many bad interactions here but recently had the pleasure of being assisted by Leroy. Amazing customer service, deserves a pay raise. He is the most pleasurable employee working there that I have personally dealt with. Keep him, I will be keeping my business here as long as he is here. 10/10 ... Read more
    zayna e. - 23 November 2024
    Overall it’s easy to rent a space. But, this particular location wasn’t really up to par. It seemed like no one cleaned it, there was always trash or people’s old belongings sitting out. And my things started to rust a bit and grow mold because the air circulation wasn’t that well. The Manager however was quick to respond to my concerns so I do appreciate that. I did move out but would try a different location if I ever need a unit again. ... Read more
    Destiny W. - 31 October 2024
    I am pretty impressed with the location, and I was really grateful & thankful for the help, patience service, and awesome customer service Ms.Ty Ridner provided. People often leave bad reviews, but a positive review was warranted. She literally did an amazing job helping us during this stressful transition. ... Read more
    clarence w. - 16 December 2023

    About this facility

    This Extra Space Storage facility at 8840 East 42nd Street in Indianapolis offers a variety of small, medium, and large units, ensuring a fit for different storage needs. The facility provides a range of modern conveniences, including climate-controlled units, ideal for protecting temperature-sensitive belongings against Indiana's humid summers and cold winters.

    The property offers indoor access with elevators for multi-level storage, making it simple to access units on higher floors. For those prioritizing easy loading and unloading, units with drive-up access are available. Vehicle owners will appreciate the parking and RV storage options, providing a safe place for cars, boats, or campers. Security is a priority at this facility, with features like a gated entry, security cameras, and an onsite manager for added peace of mind.

    This facility also emphasizes convenience with contactless renting, online payment options, and a retail area for purchasing moving supplies. Whether you're a local resident needing extra space or preparing for a big move, this Extra Space Storage facility delivers secure, accessible, and flexible solutions.

    Price comparison

    See how this facility's unit prices compare to others in Indianapolis, broken down by size.

    Small $53/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $17/mo $216/mo
    Medium $112/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $50/mo $349/mo
    Large $241/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $49/mo $1616/mo

    Location & walkability

    This storage facility is in an area with moderate walkability and some public transit options. A personal vehicle may be needed for certain trips.

    40

    out of 100

    Walk Score

    Car-Dependent

    Most errands require a car

    43

    out of 100

    Bike Score

    Somewhat Bikeable

    Minimal bike infrastructure

    Walk Score®: 40, Bike Score®: 43

    Neighborhood highlights

    Located near shopping, car wash stations, and other local conveniences, this storage facility helps you make the most of every visit.

    • Crown Autos

      Shopping 0.56 miles

    • Goodwill

      Shopping 0.7 miles

    • Bando

      Food & Drinks 0.71 miles

    • Metro by T-Mobile

      Shopping 0.72 miles

    • Morris Settles Lawrence Public Safety Building

      Services 0.76 miles

    • Hardee's

      Food & Drinks 0.78 miles

    • Lawrence Post Office

      Services 0.79 miles

    • Lawrence Fire Station 1

      Services 0.8 miles

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The right storage unit size depends on what you plan to store and how much space you need to move around your items.

    5x5 or 5x10 units are great for smaller loads, such as chairs, lamps, small furniture pieces, boxes, books, and documents.

    10x10 or 10x15 units work well for larger furniture, bicycles, appliances, and the contents of a small apartment.

    10x20 or 10x30 units can typically fit the contents of a three-bedroom home, including large furniture and multiple appliances.

    If you’re unsure which size is best, a unit size calculator can help estimate the right fit based on the items you’re planning to store – helping you avoid paying for more space than you need.

    Climate-controlled storage units maintain consistent temperature and humidity levels, helping protect items from damage caused by heat, cold, or excess moisture.

    You may want climate control if you’re storing items that can be sensitive to temperature changes, such as furniture, clothing, appliances, paperwork, photographs, artwork, electronics, or wood and leather goods. These units are especially useful for long-term storage or in areas with hot summers, cold winters, or high humidity.

    If you’re storing durable items like tools or outdoor gear, a standard unit may be sufficient. When in doubt, climate control offers added protection and peace of mind.

    The facility at 8840 East 42nd Street is accessible during regular access hours, typically Mon-Fri: 9:30 a.m. - 6 p.m., Sat: 9 a.m. - 5:30 p.m. Office hours and gate access times may differ, so it’s a good idea to check the facility’s posted schedule before your visit.

    To open your storage unit door, start by unlocking it, whether it uses a traditional padlock or a Bluetooth-enabled smart lock. Once unlocked, grab the bottom handle and lift or pull up the roll-up door until it’s fully open.

    If you’re using the unit for the first time, make sure the lock is properly removed before opening the door to avoid damage.

    Security helps protect your belongings while they’re in storage and gives you peace of mind between visits. Many self storage facilities use a combination of features such as video surveillance, gated access, on-site management, and well-lit premises to help deter unauthorized access.

    At Extra Space Storage - 8840 East 42nd Street, available security amenities may include Security Camera, Gate, Onsite Manager, designed to help keep your items protected.

    Yes, most standard vehicles can be stored in self storage units. A 10x20 unit typically provides enough space for a car, while outdoor or designated parking areas may be available for larger vehicles.

    For safety reasons, most self storage facilities restrict certain items. These commonly include:

    • Hazardous, flammable, or toxic materials
    • Perishable food
    • Live plants or animals
    • Cash, firearms, or irreplaceable valuables

    Always check with the facility at 8840 East 42nd Street for specific restrictions and recommendations.

    Storage units for rent – StorageCafe
    Contact this property now: