American Way Storage - 1109 South 19th Street, Mattoon, IL 61938

4.7/5 - 244 Reviews
Location:
1109 South 19th Street, Mattoon, IL 61938
Office hours:
  • Mon-Fri: 8:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m.
  • Sat: 8 a.m. - 10 a.m.
(217) 215-3080

American Way Storage - 1109 South 19th Street, Mattoon, IL 61938

  • Climate-Controlled

    Protect belongings from temperature changes and humidity

  • Indoor

    Units are located indoors for added protection and convenience

  • Drive-Up Access

    Drive directly up to your unit for easy loading and unloading

    Not sure which size you need? Check our size guide to find the perfect fit.
    8x12 Self Storage 96 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $115.5/mo
    8x10 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $109/mo
    6x12 Self Storage 72 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $100/mo
    6x10 Self Storage 60 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $91.5/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $83/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    $44/mo
    5x6 Self Storage 30 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $63.5/mo
    4x10 Self Storage 40 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $74/mo
    4x5 Self Storage 20 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $57/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    $94.5/mo
    10x12 Self Storage 120 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $120/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $108/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    $81/mo
    8x18 Self Storage 144 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $138/mo
    6x20 Self Storage 120 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $120/mo
    30x10 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    $135/mo
    10x40 Self Storage 400 Sq. Ft.
    $175/mo
    10x35 Self Storage 350 Sq. Ft.
    $165/mo
    10x30 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    $155/mo
    10x25 Self Storage 250 Sq. Ft.
    $133/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    $36 - $120/mo
    No units are currently available.

    Amenities & features

    • Climate-Controlled
    • Indoor
    • Drive-Up Access
    • Onsite Manager
    • Contactless Renting
    • Security Camera
    • Gate
    • Parking
    • Online Payment

    Customer reviews

    4.7/5
    Average rating
    244
    Number of reviews

    Read some helpful reviews of American Way Storage, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

    Nikki F. - 24 February 2026
    As a new customer I must say I'm very happy with the S. 19th location in Mattoon, Illinois. The gate provides extra security and the units are kept very clean. I was expecting to have to sweep my unit out but was pleasantly surprised when I didn't need to. The facility also offers a dumpster which is a nice benefit when you need to toss old boxes or unwanted items. ... Read more
    HEATHER D. - 4 February 2026
    Rashaun T. - 5 October 2025
    I had a debit card compromised from an online source, as everyone knows these days it changes all your auto payments. American Way storage was very easy to deal with to get this switched to new card and compassionate about the difficulty of the entire process ... Read more
    Michelle C. - 20 August 2025
    Kelsey F. - 7 August 2025
    I started renting storage when it was owned by jakes storage and they were wonderful. Since they went to American way it has been not so great. They keep raising the amount without any kind of letter stating as such or why just sends you a bill by text or email. They haven't done any updates to the units to justify the amount being increased and I have told them how the ceiling in my unit is falling but nothing has been done. My unit is actually way in the back in an area that is very hard to get to and they have added some units that make it even more difficult to get out so it doesn't seem justified to keep paying such a high rate for the inconvenience and for the deterioration of their unit. I will be removing my stuff as soon as I am able. Do not rent from them! They do not care as long as they get their money. ... Read more
    Natalie A. - 22 May 2025
    Very easy to book a unit, and appreciated the gated access and wonderful customer service, will definitely recommend for those going home in the summer! The 24/7 access helped tremendously with not having to rush my packing/moving process! ... Read more
    Benjamin R. - 12 May 2025
    My daughter had stuff in unit 37 and we got most of it out but I called and talked to someone several times about cleaning the rest out it was all garbage. The lady told me I had till the 5th of may to get it cleaned out or they would charge. I told her i would make sure it was out by then. Went over on Sunday the 4th may and they had placed a lock on it so I couldn’t get in to clean it. How are we suppose to make sure it’s clean and take pics if we can’t even get in to the unit. And of course they are closed. And she told me they wouldn’t lock it down that we’d have time to clean it. They are horrible to rent from. They are just trying to get another months payment from someone. ... Read more
    George M. - 4 May 2025
    So far so good! Renting a unit was super easy. Just go to the website, pick your size, pick your unit number, and pay. Easy breezy, lemon squeezie! Unit was clean and dry inside. I had a question about something mentioned on the website and called to get clarification. The lady was pleasant and knowledgeable and answered my question completely. Now to move stuff in! ... Read more
    Denise B. - 3 March 2025

    About this facility

    Located at 1109 South 19th Street in Mattoon, IL, this American Way Storage facility offers a range of unit sizes, including small, medium, and large, to accommodate your varied storage needs. Whether you're decluttering your home, making space during a move, or storing seasonal items, you'll find units that fit your requirements with ease.

    This facility provides climate-controlled units, ideal for protecting your belongings from Mattoon’s fluctuating weather conditions, from humid summers to chilly winters. Featuring indoor access and drive-up access, it ensures flexible and convenient loading options. Security is a priority with security cameras and an onsite manager to provide peace of mind. For those needing vehicle or RV storage, parking is also available. The facility is gated for added safety and security.

    A standout feature of this facility is its contactless renting process, making it easy to reserve and access your storage space. With online payment and first-floor access, this facility is a practical choice for residents and businesses in Mattoon looking for secure, hassle-free storage solutions.

    Price comparison

    See how this facility's unit prices compare to others in Mattoon, broken down by size.

    Small $82/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $44/mo $116/mo
    Medium $110/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $81/mo $138/mo
    Large $133/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $36/mo $175/mo

    Location & walkability

    This storage facility is in an area with moderate walkability and some public transit options. A personal vehicle may be needed for certain trips.

    49

    out of 100

    Walk Score

    Car-Dependent

    Most errands require a car

    47

    out of 100

    Bike Score

    Somewhat Bikeable

    Minimal bike infrastructure

    Walk Score®: 49, Bike Score®: 47

    Neighborhood highlights

    Located near shopping, car wash stations, and other local conveniences, this storage facility helps you make the most of every visit.

    • Hardee's

      Food & Drinks 0.14 miles

    • US Grant Motel

      Services 0.18 miles

    • Subway

      Food & Drinks 0.18 miles

    • Marathon

      Services 0.23 miles

    • Papa John's

      Food & Drinks 0.24 miles

    • Citgo

      Services 0.32 miles

    • Citgo

      Grocery Stores 0.32 miles

    • Sonic

      Food & Drinks 0.37 miles

    • Parrish Carpets

      Shopping 0.4 miles

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The right storage unit size depends on what you plan to store and how much space you need to move around your items.

    5x5 or 5x10 units are great for smaller loads, such as chairs, lamps, small furniture pieces, boxes, books, and documents.

    10x10 or 10x15 units work well for larger furniture, bicycles, appliances, and the contents of a small apartment.

    10x20 or 10x30 units can typically fit the contents of a three-bedroom home, including large furniture and multiple appliances.

    If you’re unsure which size is best, a unit size calculator can help estimate the right fit based on the items you’re planning to store – helping you avoid paying for more space than you need.

    Climate-controlled storage units maintain consistent temperature and humidity levels, helping protect items from damage caused by heat, cold, or excess moisture.

    You may want climate control if you’re storing items that can be sensitive to temperature changes, such as furniture, clothing, appliances, paperwork, photographs, artwork, electronics, or wood and leather goods. These units are especially useful for long-term storage or in areas with hot summers, cold winters, or high humidity.

    If you’re storing durable items like tools or outdoor gear, a standard unit may be sufficient. When in doubt, climate control offers added protection and peace of mind.

    The facility at 1109 South 19th Street is accessible during regular access hours, typically Mon-Fri: 8:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m., Sat: 8 a.m. - 10 a.m. Office hours and gate access times may differ, so it’s a good idea to check the facility’s posted schedule before your visit.

    To open your storage unit door, start by unlocking it, whether it uses a traditional padlock or a Bluetooth-enabled smart lock. Once unlocked, grab the bottom handle and lift or pull up the roll-up door until it’s fully open.

    If you’re using the unit for the first time, make sure the lock is properly removed before opening the door to avoid damage.

    Security helps protect your belongings while they’re in storage and gives you peace of mind between visits. Many self storage facilities use a combination of features such as video surveillance, gated access, on-site management, and well-lit premises to help deter unauthorized access.

    At American Way Storage - 1109 South 19th Street, available security amenities may include Security Camera, Gate, Onsite Manager, designed to help keep your items protected.

    Yes, most standard vehicles can be stored in self storage units. A 10x20 unit typically provides enough space for a car, while outdoor or designated parking areas may be available for larger vehicles.

    For safety reasons, most self storage facilities restrict certain items. These commonly include:

    • Hazardous, flammable, or toxic materials
    • Perishable food
    • Live plants or animals
    • Cash, firearms, or irreplaceable valuables

    Always check with the facility at 1109 South 19th Street for specific restrictions and recommendations.

    Storage units for rent – StorageCafe
    Contact this property now:
    (217) 215-3080