Extra Space Storage - 1 South Street, Garden City, NY 11530

5/5 - 873 Reviews
Location:
1 South Street, Garden City, NY 11530
Office hours:
24/7 ACCESS
  • Mon-Fri: 9:30 a.m. - 6 p.m.
  • Sat: 9 a.m. - 5:30 p.m.
24/7 ACCESS

Extra Space Storage - 1 South Street, Garden City, NY 11530

  • Climate-Controlled

    Protect belongings from temperature changes and humidity

  • Indoor

    Units are located indoors for added protection and convenience

  • 24 hour access

    Access your unit any time, day or night, when available

    Not sure which size you need? Check our size guide to find the perfect fit.
    16x5 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $272/mo
    11x5 Self Storage 55 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $249/mo
    11x5 Self Storage 55 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $191/mo
    10x9 Self Storage 90 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $535/mo
    10x9 Self Storage 90 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $376/mo
    10x8 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $272/mo
    10x7 Self Storage 70 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $241/mo
    10x6 Self Storage 60 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $269/mo
    10x6 Self Storage 60 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $205/mo
    10x5 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $229/mo
    10x5 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $175/mo
    10x4 Self Storage 40 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $146/mo
    9x11 Self Storage 99 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $410/mo
    9x10 Self Storage 90 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $535/mo
    9x10 Self Storage 90 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $376/mo
    9x7 Self Storage 63 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $219/mo
    9x5 Self Storage 45 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $215/mo
    9x5 Self Storage 45 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $161/mo
    8x10 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $272/mo
    8x7 Self Storage 56 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $193/mo
    7x10 Self Storage 70 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $309/mo
    7x10 Self Storage 70 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $241/mo
    7x9 Self Storage 63 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $219/mo
    7x5 Self Storage 35 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $130/mo
    6x10 Self Storage 60 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $205/mo
    6x7 Self Storage 42 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $215/mo
    6x5 Self Storage 30 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $113/mo
    6x4 Self Storage 24 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $94/mo
    5x17 Self Storage 85 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $357/mo
    5x15 Self Storage 75 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $330/mo
    5x11 Self Storage 55 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $191/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $175/mo
    5x9 Self Storage 45 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $215/mo
    5x9 Self Storage 45 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $161/mo
    5x8 Self Storage 40 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $146/mo
    5x7 Self Storage 35 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $130/mo
    5x6 Self Storage 30 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $215/mo
    5x6 Self Storage 30 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $113/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $200/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $24 - $97/mo
    5x4 Self Storage 20 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $80/mo
    4x11 Self Storage 44 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $158/mo
    4x10 Self Storage 40 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $146/mo
    4x9 Self Storage 36 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $133/mo
    4x5 Self Storage 20 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $80/mo
    19x10 Self Storage 190 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $901/mo
    15x11 Self Storage 165 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $851/mo
    15x7 Self Storage 105 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $431/mo
    11x11 Self Storage 121 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $556/mo
    11x10 Self Storage 110 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $640/mo
    11x10 Self Storage 110 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $449/mo
    10x19 Self Storage 190 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $901/mo
    10x18 Self Storage 180 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $792/mo
    10x17 Self Storage 170 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $752/mo
    10x16 Self Storage 160 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $714/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $825/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $673/mo
    10x14 Self Storage 140 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $776/mo
    10x14 Self Storage 140 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $634/mo
    10x13 Self Storage 130 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $725/mo
    10x13 Self Storage 130 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $594/mo
    10x12 Self Storage 120 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $485/mo
    10x11 Self Storage 110 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $449/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $586/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $414/mo
    9x21 Self Storage 189 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $851/mo
    9x21 Self Storage 189 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $851/mo
    9x20 Self Storage 180 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $792/mo
    9x16 Self Storage 144 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $649/mo
    9x15 Self Storage 135 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $611/mo
    9x14 Self Storage 126 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $576/mo
    8x20 Self Storage 160 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $714/mo
    25x10 Self Storage 250 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $967/mo
    24x14 Self Storage 336 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $1,238/mo
    23x9 Self Storage 207 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $967/mo
    20x25 Self Storage 500 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator Warehouse
    $1,717/mo
    20x25 Self Storage 500 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Warehouse
    $1,717/mo
    20x20 Self Storage 400 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $1,443/mo
    20x15 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $1,117/mo
    20x14 Self Storage 280 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $1,048/mo
    20x11 Self Storage 220 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $967/mo
    10x31 Self Storage 310 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $1,155/mo
    10x30 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $1,124/mo
    10x30 Self Storage 300 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $1,117/mo
    10x27 Self Storage 270 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $1,030/mo
    10x26 Self Storage 260 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $983/mo
    10x25 Self Storage 250 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $967/mo
    10x25 Self Storage 250 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $967/mo
    10x21 Self Storage 210 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $967/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $901/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled Elevator
    $901/mo
    No units are currently available.

    Amenities & features

    • Climate-Controlled
    • Indoor
    • 24 hour access
    • Retail Available
    • Onsite Manager
    • Contactless Renting
    • Security Camera
    • Gate
    • Parking
    • Elevators
    • Multi-Level Storage
    • Online Payment

    Customer reviews

    5/5
    Average rating
    873
    Number of reviews

    Read some helpful reviews of Extra Space Storage, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

    Julia M. - 2 June 2026
    My experience renting at Extra Space Storage facility was pleasant. They have competitive rates and the facility is clean and dry and very well lighted. My interaction with Ricky James the store manager was encouraging. I would highly recommend Extra Space Storage. ... Read more
    Roberta D. - 5 May 2026
    I had a great experience with Extra Space Storage! The facility is clean, secure, and very well-maintained. The staff is friendly, helpful, and made the entire process quick and stress-free. I also appreciated how easy it was to access my unit and how organized everything felt. Highly recommend to anyone looking for reliable storage in the area! ... Read more
    Natalie I. - 15 April 2026
    Ricky was fabulous! There was an issue with my unit and he fixed it without me having to even worry about it. He was pleasant over the phone and got everything handled immediately. I world recommend Extra Space Storage and Ricky to anyone looking for a place to store things for a short or a long time! My experience has been 10/10 ... Read more
    Jessica L. - 7 April 2026
    Chrys P. - 4 March 2026
    Chee absolutely changed my life. He is so amazing, so gentle, so calm, so helpful & may I add how handsome he is? If I could make it 6 stars I would. As a matter fact I feel like you guys should give him a 15% stake in the company. Thank you Mr. Vilain for your kindness & hospitality ?? ... Read more
    Pierre D. - 3 March 2026
    Jon S. - 26 February 2026
    I had a great experience renting a storage unit. Shay was incredibly attentive and helpful from start to finish. He took the time to show us different units, answered all our questions, and made the whole process easy and stress-free. He was very kind and professional, and I really appreciated how well he treated us. Highly recommend this location, its also very clean and well maintained. ... Read more
    Denise L. - 13 December 2025
    I have only been using Extra Storage for only a year and they doubled the cost of my unit. They told us we can reduce our cost by moving our stuff into a larger unit, which doesn’t make any sense. This place is a scam!! They will keep increasing your price until you leave. Don’t recommend ?? ... Read more
    Allyson C. - 1 November 2025
    Great and fast service. Ricky James is a great manager. Always has a smile on his face and positive attitude. He was so helpful in showing me different size units and explaining everything to me thoroughly. Definitely would recommend extra space storage to anyone and everyone. ... Read more
    isamar m. - 30 October 2025
    I AM ANOTHER SATISFIED CUSTOMER! I was assisted by Mardochée Vilain. He was extreamly helpful, knowlesgible, patient, and courteous. I have a unit at another location and he helped me consolidate all my storage lockers under my one account. He also took the time to show me around the Garden City facility to help me pick the units that best suited me. ... Read more
    Henry S. - 29 October 2025
    Bently - 3 October 2025
    I’ve had an excellent experience with this storage facility thanks to Al and Ricky. Since opening my unit, both of them have been extremely helpful, professional, and friendly. They made the entire process smooth and easy, from explaining the unit options to walking me through the paperwork and answering all my questions. Their customer service goes above and beyond – I always feel welcomed and valued when I stop by. Highly recommend this location because of their great assistance and positive attitudes. Thank you, Al and Ricky, for everything! ... Read more
    D W. - 17 July 2025
    Wow! Great experience for our very specific needs. Ijenna is an incredibly professional and pleasant agent. She really helped me a lot and had a lot of patience with walking me through steps I needed to secure my space. Highly recommend! We went to see the unit today and the person there was very helpful and friendly. The space was clean and looked secure. Highly recommend! ... Read more
    Kristen R. - 24 June 2025
    Belania D. - 11 June 2025
    Rick has been phenomenal from our very first conversation. Getting me exactly what I need and going as far as making me feel comfortable and confident over my December snowy Sunday move in! He’s stayed close even sharing imperative price increases and DSS notifications before even receiving them myself. I feel beyond Blessed that Rick picked up my call that day in November. Quickly and accurately figured out the appropriate storage size and put me at immense ease while quickly planning my escape to a DV shelter. I am Beyond Blessed and know, so are all of You to have him as one of your beyond Top employees! Thank you! -Alison Brent And happily my second stellar review of his… ??… Him! So yes, please, if you haven’t already thrown him his deserving acknowledgment recognition party with cupcakes and everything else he might want and that raise And promotion, please… It’s way over due! ?? He is exactly what you All dreamed/prayed for when creating your Mission statement ?????? ... Read more
    Alison - 22 April 2025
    Great experience at Extra Space Storage on South St, Garden City. Mardochee Vilain , the assistant manager gave me a tour of some rental spaces available based on my needs. He wasted no time finding the perfect location and size. I am very satisfied with the space he offered. The rental process was quick and easy. Highly recommend seeing this gentleman for your storage needs. Very pleasant experience! ... Read more
    Bruce S. - 21 March 2025
    Great service my a representative Mr.Mardochée… got everything set-up quickly and easy. Friendly environment and get good deals for monthly payments. Also there’s a app to open gates to park inside storage away from any bad climate days. ... Read more
    K V. - 4 March 2025
    I’ve had a unit here for about two years now and I’ve never had an issue. Clean unit, good music playing and I always feel safe. Everyone is always so polite and helpful, ESPECIALLY RICK!! Mr. James, thank you so much for being helpful AND comical at the same time. I truly so appreciate your level of professionalism and exemplary customer service ?? ... Read more
    Jenn K. - 3 January 2025
    I am at the life storage in garden city, Zaf and Rick James were such a delight and very kind and took their time to serve me and my partner. I’m currently moving out of an old storage unit and their process is very straightforward ... Read more
    BCD P. - 2 January 2025
    I had a great experience renting a storage unit here. The process was smooth and straightforward. Ricky, the store manager, was especially helpful—he answered all my questions, provided useful advice on the right size of storage, and made sure I understood everything.Highly recommend this place for anyone in need of storage! ... Read more
    Dada Z. - 14 October 2024

    About this facility

    Located at 1 South Street in Garden City, NY, this Extra Space Storage facility offers a variety of unit sizes, including small, medium, and large, to accommodate diverse storage needs. For residents of Garden City, where homes often feature limited storage space, this facility is a convenient solution for keeping belongings secure and organized.

    This facility stands out with its climate-controlled units, an essential feature for the fluctuating weather in New York. These units help protect sensitive items such as electronics, photographs, and wooden furniture from temperature and humidity changes. Featuring indoor access and elevators, this multi-level facility ensures ease of use, even when managing heavy or bulky items. The property is equipped with security cameras and an onsite manager, offering peace of mind with a strong focus on safety. For added flexibility, this facility provides 24-hour access, parking, and contactless renting options, making it simple to store and retrieve items anytime.

    With convenient online payment options and moving supplies available for purchase onsite, this Extra Space Storage facility is a top choice for residents, families, and businesses in need of a secure and accessible storage solution in Garden City.

    Price comparison

    See how this facility's unit prices compare to others in East Garden City, broken down by size.

    Small $220/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $24/mo $535/mo
    Medium $674/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $189/mo $901/mo
    Large $1121/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $349/mo $1717/mo

    Location & walkability

    This storage facility is in a highly accessible area with excellent walkability and public transit options.

    56

    out of 100

    Walk Score

    Somewhat Walkable

    Some errands can be accomplished on foot

    50

    out of 100

    Transit Score

    Good Transit

    Many nearby public transportation options

    58

    out of 100

    Bike Score

    Bikeable

    Some bike infrastructure

    Walk Score®: 56, Transit Score®: 50, Bike Score®: 58

    Neighborhood highlights

    Located near shopping, car wash stations, and other local conveniences, this storage facility helps you make the most of every visit.

    • Mobil

      Services 0.04 miles

    • La Quinta Inn

      Services 0.07 miles

    • Stewart Avenue & Quentin Roosevelt Boulevard

      Transportation 0.07 miles

    • Garden Gourmet Restaurant

      Food & Drinks 0.1 miles

    • 830 Stewart Avenue

      Transportation 0.11 miles

    • Ethen Allen

      Shopping 0.12 miles

    • USPS

      Services 0.12 miles

    • 845 Stewart Avenue

      Transportation 0.12 miles

    • Hampton

      Shopping 0.14 miles

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The right storage unit size depends on what you plan to store and how much space you need to move around your items.

    5x5 or 5x10 units are great for smaller loads, such as chairs, lamps, small furniture pieces, boxes, books, and documents.

    10x10 or 10x15 units work well for larger furniture, bicycles, appliances, and the contents of a small apartment.

    10x20 or 10x30 units can typically fit the contents of a three-bedroom home, including large furniture and multiple appliances.

    If you’re unsure which size is best, a unit size calculator can help estimate the right fit based on the items you’re planning to store – helping you avoid paying for more space than you need.

    Climate-controlled storage units maintain consistent temperature and humidity levels, helping protect items from damage caused by heat, cold, or excess moisture.

    You may want climate control if you’re storing items that can be sensitive to temperature changes, such as furniture, clothing, appliances, paperwork, photographs, artwork, electronics, or wood and leather goods. These units are especially useful for long-term storage or in areas with hot summers, cold winters, or high humidity.

    If you’re storing durable items like tools or outdoor gear, a standard unit may be sufficient. When in doubt, climate control offers added protection and peace of mind.

    The facility at 1 South Street offers 24/7 access, allowing you to visit your unit at your convenience.

    To open your storage unit door, start by unlocking it, whether it uses a traditional padlock or a Bluetooth-enabled smart lock. Once unlocked, grab the bottom handle and lift or pull up the roll-up door until it’s fully open.

    If you’re using the unit for the first time, make sure the lock is properly removed before opening the door to avoid damage.

    Security helps protect your belongings while they’re in storage and gives you peace of mind between visits. Many self storage facilities use a combination of features such as video surveillance, gated access, on-site management, and well-lit premises to help deter unauthorized access.

    At Extra Space Storage - 1 South Street, available security amenities may include Security Camera, Gate, Onsite Manager, designed to help keep your items protected.

    Yes, most standard vehicles can be stored in self storage units. A 10x20 unit typically provides enough space for a car, while outdoor or designated parking areas may be available for larger vehicles.

    For safety reasons, most self storage facilities restrict certain items. These commonly include:

    • Hazardous, flammable, or toxic materials
    • Perishable food
    • Live plants or animals
    • Cash, firearms, or irreplaceable valuables

    Always check with the facility at 1 South Street for specific restrictions and recommendations.

    Storage units for rent – StorageCafe
    Contact this property now: