Storage units for rent – StorageCafe
Contact this property now:
(765) 246-8941

Storage Crib - 2146 Troy Avenue, New Castle, IN 47362

Self Storage, Car Storage, RV Storage 45 - 1,560 Sq. Ft.
4/5 - 86 Reviews
(765) 246-8941
Location:
2146 Troy Avenue, New Castle, IN 47362
All units
Small
Medium
Large
Parking
Loading... Loading results...
Units Availability
Small Storage Unit
10x8
Self Storage
80 Sq. Ft.
$77/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x7
Self Storage
70 Sq. Ft.
$32/mo
Small Storage Unit
10x5
Self Storage
50 Sq. Ft.
$47 - $64/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x7
Self Storage
56 Sq. Ft.
$58/mo
Small Storage Unit
8x6
Self Storage
48 Sq. Ft.
$55/mo
Small Storage Unit
7x10
Self Storage
70 Sq. Ft.
$64 - $92/mo
Small Storage Unit
6x12
Self Storage
72 Sq. Ft.
$69/mo
Small Storage Unit
6x10
Self Storage
60 Sq. Ft.
$37/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x12
Self Storage
60 Sq. Ft.
$79/mo
Small Storage Unit
5x9
Self Storage
45 Sq. Ft.
$36/mo
Medium Storage Unit
13x15
Self Storage
195 Sq. Ft.
$126/mo
Medium Storage Unit
12x15
Self Storage
180 Sq. Ft.
$116/mo
Medium Storage Unit
12x12
Self Storage
144 Sq. Ft.
$111/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x16
Self Storage
160 Sq. Ft.
$148/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x15
Self Storage
150 Sq. Ft.
$84/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x12
Self Storage
120 Sq. Ft.
$109 - $112/mo
Medium Storage Unit
10x10
Self Storage
100 Sq. Ft.
$77 - $133/mo
Medium Storage Unit
7x18
Self Storage
126 Sq. Ft.
$74/mo
Large Storage Unit
42x24
Self Storage
1,008 Sq. Ft.
$539/mo
Large Storage Unit
40x24
Self Storage
960 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$445/mo
Large Storage Unit
39x40
Self Storage
1,560 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$594/mo
Large Storage Unit
33x40
Self Storage
1,320 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$594/mo
Large Storage Unit
30x40
Self Storage
1,200 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$582/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x40
Self Storage
800 Sq. Ft.
$397/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x33
Self Storage
660 Sq. Ft.
$339/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x25
Self Storage
500 Sq. Ft.
$267/mo
Large Storage Unit
20x20
Self Storage
400 Sq. Ft.
$207/mo
Large Storage Unit
19x26
Self Storage
494 Sq. Ft.
$254/mo
Large Storage Unit
18x35
Self Storage
630 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$291/mo
Large Storage Unit
16x40
Self Storage
640 Sq. Ft.
$345/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x30
Self Storage
450 Sq. Ft.
$231/mo
Large Storage Unit
15x20
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
$179/mo
Large Storage Unit
12x42
Self Storage
504 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$253/mo
Large Storage Unit
12x40
Parking
480 Sq. Ft.
Parking
RV Storage
$79/mo
Large Storage Unit
12x35
Self Storage
420 Sq. Ft.
Warehouse
$194/mo
Large Storage Unit
12x30
Parking
360 Sq. Ft.
Parking
RV Storage
$52/mo
Large Storage Unit
12x25
Self Storage
300 Sq. Ft.
$184/mo
Large Storage Unit
12x20
Self Storage
240 Sq. Ft.
$140/mo
Large Storage Unit
11x35
Self Storage
385 Sq. Ft.
$192/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x40
Parking
400 Sq. Ft.
Parking
RV Storage
$62/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x25
Self Storage
250 Sq. Ft.
$145/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x21
Self Storage
210 Sq. Ft.
$175/mo
Large Storage Unit
10x20
Self Storage
200 Sq. Ft.
$109/mo

Amenities

  • Climate-Controlled
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Onsite Manager
  • Contactless Renting
  • Security Camera
  • Gate
  • Parking
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Online Payment
  • RV Storage

What customers are saying

4/5 - 86 Reviews

Read some helpful reviews of Storage Crib at 2146 Troy Avenue, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

Charles C. - 3 October 2025
I have been a LOYAL customer for many years, now that there are new owners everything has been chaos. 1st off when you call during normal business hours, noone answers the phone, took 5 days to receive a simple call back after I had sent an email. My rent has always been deducted on the 10th. In Aug I noticed payment wasnt deducted so I called(the only time they ever answered) and lady said I wasnt set up on auto pay and that all payments are due on the 1st...which I have been for years on auto pay so I thought ok no problem...gave her my card info and she said it went thru. Same week I check my bank acct info and noticed a 33.00 payment when I have always paid 17.41. Needless to say it bounced my bank acct. Days go by no call back. Today she calls, says "ya all our prices have changed and that corporate did it to everyones. I told her she did NOT inform me of any payment changes and all she says was Im pretty sure I told you and I mean we can go back and listen to recording. I told her she needs to and asked for corporates phone number. Says she cant give out number, only email. Just sent email. Will update review after getting feedback if any. *Update#1* STILL have not heard back. Also called today...no answer(09/13/21).*Update#2* Received email on (09/14/21). Pics attached * Update #3. (09/14/21) received phone call from "corporate" office to apologize & state that they mailed me letter of price increase which I never got & that the other worker is no longer working at this location. No credit to acct or anything. All around a joke of a company now. What a shame. Soon as I can get to my storage unit Im cancelling my service. Updated- Now they are requiring everyone and changing contract to have insurance! Now bill will be even higher!!!! Also front gate hasnt been locked in MONTHS. Update #2- Received an email of more FEES!!!! See last pic Update #3- Now they think its funny to never reply if their broken gate is fixed or not and send multiple emails back to back to back about their lame fundraiser. No One cares!!! People care if the gate is fixed Update #4*** Now they have raised their prices again for the 2nd time since taking over, 18 more bucks EACH month!!! So from being a loyal customer for years paying 17.41 with excellent service to now my bill is 59.00 ...poor service ******UPDATE****** My bill has went up 3 more times since my review. It is now 108!!!!! Total rip off. Also this last bill increase I was NEVER notified that it would be increasing. If you're considering renting a unit from here...please don't..Save yourself the headache and that being a loyal customer here doesn't do shit.oh and their response just now is all fluff lol they do not care and still never reached out to me notifying of another rent increase. So no I will not email you bc it does nothing. ... Read more
FlReelAnglers - 4 August 2025
Curtis - 11 March 2025
I wish I could give zero stars. In 2020 we were paying $60.11 for storage here. Then a new company took over. Osprey, or whatever. Evidently they like to rip people off so that they can buy more properties and expand parking lots and such. Or probably more so for the big wigs to get rich. They may be taking lessons from the health insurance companies. Anyway, $60.11. Over the last few years, after the old company raised the rent ONCE IN FIVE YEARS FOR $5, the new company has since raised the rent 11 cents short of $30. The rent has gone from $60.11 to $90 in just over 3 years. Do yourself a favor and look at one of the other storage places in town. I know personally that at least one of them grandfathers your price. Whatever price they give you is the one you will pay until you stop renting. But not this place. Nope. ???? This place will raise your rent about $10 per year. My rent has gone up 50% in just a few years. It went up once from 2011-2020, like I said, for FIVE DOLLARS. The amount of rental increases here is absolutely ridiculous and someone is getting rich off of it. Y’all should absolutely be ashamed of yourself for doing this AGAIN, and SO SOON. Why couldn’t you at least wait a few years? But you couldn’t, could you? Because you want to make sure everyone gets used to a yearly increase. So the old company gave one increase over almost 10 years at approximately 9%. This company has increased our rent by 50% in just over 3-3.5 years. 0 stars F minus FAIL ... Read more
Crowley &. - 27 December 2024
Julia b. - 2 April 2024
I recently had to move to Texas for a few months for work. moving out of my apartment here but, I would like to return in the future when my assignment is up. I left my belongings at storage crib and am pleased upon coming back for the long weekend all belongings nice and safe in an easy to access area. plus I would say it is a very reasonable price for the size of the unit I have. ... Read more
Nick S. - 4 March 2022
It's okay. Maybe overpriced for the condition the units are in. If you don't like spiders or water damage, then don't store anything here, unless you specifically get a climate controlled, weatherized unit. UPDATE: They are raising our monthly fee for upkeep or something like that. Yet there is a massive puddle in front of our unit that for over a year they have not filled in or dug drainage for and it combined with insects and dirt is ruining our belongings. I don't recommend any of their non-weatherized units. ... Read more
Sondra H. - 2 August 2021

Overview

Located on Troy Avenue in New Castle, this Storage Crib facility offers a range of unit sizes, including small, medium, and large, to fit a variety of storage needs. Whether you’re decluttering your home, storing seasonal items, or looking for more space during a move, this facility has you covered.

This facility features climate-controlled units, ideal for protecting items from Indiana’s humid summers and cold winters. With drive-up access, loading and unloading heavy or bulky items is convenient and hassle-free. For added peace of mind, the property is equipped with security cameras, a gated entry system, and an onsite manager. Need to store a vehicle or RV? This location also provides parking and RV storage options, making it a great choice for recreational vehicles or extra cars.

For added convenience, this Storage Crib facility supports contactless renting and online payment, so managing your storage unit is quick and easy. Perfect for residents in New Castle looking for flexible, secure storage solutions.

Storage units in nearby cities

Want to see how New Castle, IN, compares to other places? There are plenty of great options nearby. Muncie, IN, 19 miles away, has 14 self storage facilities with rents starting from $15/month. Or you could drive to Pendleton, IN, just 21 miles distant to find other options, where the cheapest units in the 3 facilities there can be rented for $44/month. In Anderson, IN, just 22 miles away, there are 12 facilities available, offering rents as low as $25/month. Further out, Greenfield, IN (24 miles away), and Alexandria, IN (27 miles away), have 9 and 1 facilities, with minimum rents of $50 and $60, respectively.

Storage units in Muncie, IN Within a 19-mile radius
14 Facilities
From $15/mo
Storage units in Pendleton, IN Within a 21-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $44/mo
Storage units in Anderson, IN Within a 22-mile radius
12 Facilities
From $25/mo
Storage units in Greenfield, IN Within a 24-mile radius
9 Facilities
From $50/mo
Storage units in Alexandria, IN Within a 27-mile radius
1 Facility
From $60/mo
Storage units in McCordsville, IN Within a 29-mile radius
1 Facility
From $79/mo
Storage units in New Palestine, IN Within a 32-mile radius
4 Facilities
From $43/mo
Storage units in Lawrence, IN Within a 34-mile radius
7 Facilities
From $28/mo
Storage units in Elwood, IN Within a 36-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $59/mo
Storage units in Shelbyville, IN Within a 36-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $65/mo
Storage units in Cicero, IN Within a 39-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $50/mo
Storage units in Beech Grove, IN Within a 41-mile radius
2 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Oxford, OH Within a 44-mile radius
1 Facility
From $44/mo
Storage units in Westfield, IN Within a 44-mile radius
3 Facilities
From $55/mo
Storage units in Southport, IN Within a 45-mile radius
1 Facility
From $30/mo
Storage units in Greenwood, IN Within a 47-mile radius
7 Facilities
From $20/mo

Check out storage units in trending cities

Still looking for the ideal storage unit? For more great self storage options you wouldn't have to cross the state border: units can be leased in Indianapolis, IN and Fort Wayne, IN, starting from $10 and $15, respectively. Even more storage is available and with low starting rents, in South Bend, IN ($20), Fishers, IN ($20) and Carmel, IN ($49).

Storage units in Indianapolis, IN
110 Facilities
From $10/mo
Storage units in Fort Wayne, IN
30 Facilities
From $15/mo
Storage units in South Bend, IN
11 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Fishers, IN
8 Facilities
From $20/mo
Storage units in Carmel, IN
8 Facilities
From $49/mo
Storage units in Bloomington, IN
10 Facilities
From $30/mo
Storage units in Hammond, IN
6 Facilities
From $28/mo
Storage units in Noblesville, IN
14 Facilities
From $21/mo
Storage units in Lafayette, IN
17 Facilities
From $10/mo
Storage units in Gary, IN
2 Facilities
From $37/mo
Browse storage units in all Indiana cities.

Frequently Asked Questions

There is a wide array of amenities available for the storage units that Storage Crib - 2146 Troy Avenue has to offer. These amenities include Climate-Controlled, Drive-Up Access, Onsite Manager, Contactless Renting, Security Camera, Gate, Parking, Credit Cards Accepted, Online Payment and RV Storage. Most of these amenities can prove to be very useful depending on what you need to store. For example, climate-controlled units can come in handy for keeping sensitive items, drive-up access can make your loading and unloading process easier, and extra security measures will ensure your items are kept safe at all times.

The storage units offered by Storage Crib - 2146 Troy Avenue can satisfy all of your storage needs. Different sizes here range from 45 to 1,560 square feet. You can go for smaller units if you don't have a lot of items to store, while choosing a larger space is recommended in case you need to store a lot of furniture, bigger items or even vehicles.

The unit size that you should choose obviously depends on how much stuff you need to store. On the one hand, you should think of smaller units (5'x5' or 5'x10') as closets – they can be used to store chairs, lamps, moving boxes and sports equipment, along with smaller pieces of furniture, books and documents.

On the other hand, the 10'x10' and 10'x15' spaces are good for storing larger items of furniture, bicycles and a larger number of possessions. If you need even more space, then 10'x20' and 10'x30' units can easily accommodate the contents of an entire 3- or 4-bedroom house.

Storage units offered by Storage Crib - 2146 Troy Avenue come at a variety of prices, starting from $32 per month for typically smaller units. However, larger spaces can set you back up to $594 a month.

We know that when it comes to self storage, there is nothing more important than quickness and accessibility. Drive-up access is an extremely convenient amenity, as you can park your vehicle right next to your unit, making it significantly easier to load and unload the items you will use storage for. However, drive-up storage units tend to be outdoors, so you might consider indoor storage spaces with climate control if you're looking to keep temperature-sensitive items in peak condition.

Yes, you might, depending on what you need to put in storage. Climate-controlled spaces keep temperatures and humidity levels consistent all the time, which means they are perfect for storing sensitive items. Seeing that a whole host of things can be damaged by varying temperatures and excessive moisture, many people choose to rent climate-controlled units for personal items such as documents, photographs, paintings, collectibles, electronics, wooden furniture, antiques and even vehicles. If you're looking to store such items that are valuable to you, consider renting a climate-controlled unit!