Extra Space Storage - 173 West Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

4.9/5 - 292 Reviews
Location:
173 West Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
Office hours:
  • Mon-Fri: 9:30 a.m. - 6 p.m.
  • Sat: 9 a.m. - 5:30 p.m.

Extra Space Storage - 173 West Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  • Climate-Controlled

    Protect belongings from temperature changes and humidity

  • Indoor

    Units are located indoors for added protection and convenience

  • Drive-Up Access

    Drive directly up to your unit for easy loading and unloading

    Not sure which size you need? Check our size guide to find the perfect fit.
    10x5 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    $218/mo
    8x10 Self Storage 80 Sq. Ft.
    $281/mo
    5x15 Self Storage 75 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $314/mo
    5x15 Self Storage 75 Sq. Ft.
    Elevator Access
    $265 - $298/mo
    5x15 Self Storage 75 Sq. Ft.
    $258 - $370/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $241/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    Elevator Access
    $190 - $207/mo
    5x10 Self Storage 50 Sq. Ft.
    $178 - $335/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $59 - $143/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    Elevator Access
    $50 - $126/mo
    5x5 Self Storage 25 Sq. Ft.
    $47 - $107/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $499/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    Elevator Access
    $349 - $399/mo
    10x15 Self Storage 150 Sq. Ft.
    $343 - $477/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Climate-Controlled
    $380 - $388/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    Elevator Access
    $265 - $298/mo
    10x10 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    $258 - $370/mo
    5x20 Self Storage 100 Sq. Ft.
    $370/mo
    10x30 Vehicle 300 Sq. Ft.
    Drive-up Access Parking RV Storage
    $885/mo
    10x20 Self Storage 200 Sq. Ft.
    $607/mo
    10x20 Vehicle 200 Sq. Ft.
    Car Storage Parking
    $207 - $675/mo
    No units are currently available.

    Amenities & features

    • Climate-Controlled
    • Indoor
    • Drive-Up Access
    • Retail Available
    • Onsite Manager
    • Contactless Renting
    • Security Camera
    • Gate
    • Parking
    • Credit Cards Accepted
    • Enclosed
    • Elevators
    • Multi-Level Storage
    • Online Payment
    • RV Storage

    Customer reviews

    4.9/5
    Average rating
    292
    Number of reviews

    Read some helpful reviews of Extra Space Storage, shared by real renters with genuine experiences and honest opinions.

    First time customer. Spoke to April on the phone & she was fantastic. Told me to go to the location & Mary will set me up and she did. Mary directed me to the right location, she helped me set up the lock and she was incredibly kind and supportive. I recommend this Extra Space Storage to all. Ask fur April when you call & Mary when you come in. ... Read more
    A G. - 26 June 2026
    jen d. - 13 February 2026
    Mitchell L. - 7 February 2026
    Maria K. - 12 January 2026
    No one was in the office when I came in to fill out paperwork for my rental. There was a phone number on the door and someone responded and showed up immediately as they were on the premises attending to other. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable and reviewed the options and pricing and were able to offer better rates than discussed over the phone! So far my experience has been very good am happy to know that they will be able to meet my needs as they grow! ... Read more
    Mike M. - 27 September 2025
    Eileen S. - 23 September 2025
    My experience with ESS is that they keep giving you rate increases. Although Mary in the Hampton Bays office is very personable and she advocates for the customers especially if you’re on a fixed income and a disabled senior to help keep your rates from jumping too high. ... Read more
    Laraine L. - 25 June 2025
    No one was in the office when I came in to Fill out paperwork for my rental. It was a phone number on the door and someone responded and showed up immediately as they were attending to other matters on the premises. They were very friendly and knowledgeable and reviewed the pricing and was able to offer even better rates than were discussed on the phone! So far my experience has been very good and love knowing that as my needs Grau, they will be able to meet them! ... Read more
    Mike M. - 30 May 2025
    Absolutely amazing service!! They are so accommodating and really went above and beyond when I was in a real pickle and lost my keys! They stay opened late to cut the lock for me so I could get there after work. Amazing! I am so thankful! ... Read more
    KC M. - 14 April 2025
    Marie` G. - 29 March 2025
    I can’t say enough possitives about this place. When I took over an old storage space from a family member, the team was incredibly helpful helping me navigate from afar. I especially want to thank Mary for her amazing support. From the start, she helped lower the cost of my space. She would answer the phone ready to help me with all that I needed. She was so helpful with ensuring I would be able to get into the space by checking if the lock needed to be cut. I want to thank Mary and everyone at extra space for making this process so smooth! ... Read more
    Allegra N. - 23 February 2025
    This facility in Hampton Bays just off 27 is convenient to anyone who might live in the Hamptons but needs storage. It is also well maintained. My one complaint is that they are constantly raising my rate—basically every 6 months. The good news is that Mary, who has been working there for at least the two years I have rented, has been extremely helpful in helping me moderate these rate increases. Sure would be nice if the powers that be would stop with their every-6-month increases. It’s been worse than the facility in Manhattan from which I moved. ... Read more
    Jon C. - 2 January 2025
    Had an absolutely amazing experience working with Mary! She reached out multiple times to confirm my accommodations and was super kind about changing my move in date last minute as my movers were delayed. Do not hesitate to rent from this location! ... Read more
    Jordan N. - 24 October 2024
    I’ve been a client of Life Storage for a few years now, first in Southampton and now Hampton Bays. I wanted to upgrade my storage unit for my business and went to the office. Mary at the front desk was courteous, helpful and accommodating. She made the transition seamless and I now have the space to meet my current needs. The unit was clean and ready to move in same day. Thank you for great customer service! ... Read more
    Hamptons O. - 22 June 2024

    About this facility

    This Extra Space Storage facility, located at 173 West Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays, NY, offers a variety of storage solutions with small, medium, and large units to suit different needs. The climate-controlled units are ideal for protecting sensitive items like furniture, electronics, and clothing from the seasonal temperature swings and coastal humidity typical in the Hamptons.

    Features such as drive-up access and elevators make loading and unloading hassle-free, whether on the ground floor or in the multi-level storage areas. For those requiring additional flexibility, this facility provides contactless renting and accepts online payments, making the entire process convenient and efficient. The property also offers indoor access units, along with parking and dedicated RV storage, which is especially valuable for residents and visitors who need secure storage for their vehicles when not exploring the nearby beaches or local attractions.

    With advanced security measures like security cameras, a gated entry system, and an onsite manager, this facility ensures peace of mind for customers. Its combination of modern amenities and convenient features makes it an excellent choice for both long-term Hampton Bays residents and seasonal visitors needing secure, accessible storage.

    Price comparison

    See how this facility's unit prices compare to others in Hampton Bays, broken down by size.

    Small $191/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $47/mo $314/mo
    Medium $352/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $258/mo $499/mo
    Large $566/mo
    Location minimum Location maximum
    $207/mo $885/mo

    Location & walkability

    This storage facility is in a highly accessible area with excellent walkability and public transit options.

    55

    out of 100

    Walk Score

    Somewhat Walkable

    Some errands can be accomplished on foot

    46

    out of 100

    Bike Score

    Somewhat Bikeable

    Minimal bike infrastructure

    Walk Score®: 55, Bike Score®: 46

    Neighborhood highlights

    Located near shopping, car wash stations, and other local conveniences, this storage facility helps you make the most of every visit.

    • Hampton Bays - Eastbound

      Transportation 0.09 miles

    • Hampton Bays - Westbound

      Transportation 0.1 miles

    • McDonald's

      Food & Drinks 0.13 miles

    • Panera Bread

      Food & Drinks 0.16 miles

    • Hampton Bays Plaza

      Shopping 0.21 miles

    • Montauk Highway/Riverhead Hampton Bays Rd

      Transportation 0.21 miles

    • Macy's

      Shopping 0.23 miles

    • Shell

      Services 0.26 miles

    • Montauk Highway/Riverhead Hampton Bays Rd

      Transportation 0.28 miles

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The right storage unit size depends on what you plan to store and how much space you need to move around your items.

    5x5 or 5x10 units are great for smaller loads, such as chairs, lamps, small furniture pieces, boxes, books, and documents.

    10x10 or 10x15 units work well for larger furniture, bicycles, appliances, and the contents of a small apartment.

    10x20 or 10x30 units can typically fit the contents of a three-bedroom home, including large furniture and multiple appliances.

    If you’re unsure which size is best, a unit size calculator can help estimate the right fit based on the items you’re planning to store – helping you avoid paying for more space than you need.

    Climate-controlled storage units maintain consistent temperature and humidity levels, helping protect items from damage caused by heat, cold, or excess moisture.

    You may want climate control if you’re storing items that can be sensitive to temperature changes, such as furniture, clothing, appliances, paperwork, photographs, artwork, electronics, or wood and leather goods. These units are especially useful for long-term storage or in areas with hot summers, cold winters, or high humidity.

    If you’re storing durable items like tools or outdoor gear, a standard unit may be sufficient. When in doubt, climate control offers added protection and peace of mind.

    The facility at 173 West Montauk Hwy is accessible during regular access hours, typically Mon-Fri: 9:30 a.m. - 6 p.m., Sat: 9 a.m. - 5:30 p.m. Office hours and gate access times may differ, so it’s a good idea to check the facility’s posted schedule before your visit.

    To open your storage unit door, start by unlocking it, whether it uses a traditional padlock or a Bluetooth-enabled smart lock. Once unlocked, grab the bottom handle and lift or pull up the roll-up door until it’s fully open.

    If you’re using the unit for the first time, make sure the lock is properly removed before opening the door to avoid damage.

    Security helps protect your belongings while they’re in storage and gives you peace of mind between visits. Many self storage facilities use a combination of features such as video surveillance, gated access, on-site management, and well-lit premises to help deter unauthorized access.

    At Extra Space Storage - 173 West Montauk Hwy, available security amenities may include Security Camera, Gate, Onsite Manager, designed to help keep your items protected.

    Yes, most standard vehicles can be stored in self storage units. A 10x20 unit typically provides enough space for a car, while outdoor or designated parking areas may be available for larger vehicles.

    For safety reasons, most self storage facilities restrict certain items. These commonly include:

    • Hazardous, flammable, or toxic materials
    • Perishable food
    • Live plants or animals
    • Cash, firearms, or irreplaceable valuables

    Always check with the facility at 173 West Montauk Hwy for specific restrictions and recommendations.

    Storage units for rent – StorageCafe
    Contact this property now: