Storage units in Middle Island, NY, and nearby areas

389 available units | 20 facilities

Joe at extra space took care of me and made my experience simple , fast and pleasant.
Nick Tartaglia

Contactless
4.9/5 - 618 Reviews
Extra Space Storage, Middle Island, NY 11953
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $80/mo
10' x 10' Medium $192/mo
10' x 20' Large $309/mo
View Details
One of the best storage companies. Personnel were great. Especially the new kid John.
JERRY WEIDNER

Contactless
4.9/5 - 715 Reviews
Devon Self Storage, Yaphank, NY 11980
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $65/mo
10' x 10' Medium $163/mo
12' x 30' Large $89/mo
View Details
I needed a parking space for my RV for the winter. Daniel was very helpful selecting the best spot for us, and reviewing all the paperwork. It was a great experience, and a perfect location to store an RV near Cathedral Pines. Thanks!!
Wayne Miller
4.9/5 - 871 Reviews
Extra Space Storage, Ridge, NY 11961
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $71/mo
10' x 10' Medium $165/mo
8' x 25' Large $135/mo
View Details
10/10 will rent from riss again. Wonderful human.
Mike Scala

Contactless
4.7/5 - 339 Reviews
Public Storage, Coram, NY 11727
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $57/mo
8' x 15' Medium $92/mo
10' x 20' Large $353/mo
View Details
Saved me a lot of money super friendly and helpful
Wesley Beauchamp

Contactless
4.6/5 - 206 Reviews
Prime Storage, Medford, NY 11763
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- 24 hour access
5' x 5' Small $57/mo
12' x 16' Medium $106/mo
12' x 20' Large $142/mo
View Details
How much space do you need?
Use our calculator to quickly find the right unit size for your belongings.
Find My Unit Size
Alex was great the entire time . This whole process has been tough for me but Alex was able to make it easy and understandable
ANDREA BATTISTA

Contactless
4.7/5 - 332 Reviews
Public Storage, Mount Sinai, NY 11766
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $64/mo
10' x 10' Medium $220/mo
10' x 20' Large $376/mo
View Details
Genevieve was totally transparent and clear in presenting the plans, pros & cons of each and was professional. Fair pricing! We recommend working w them
Gail Toma

Contactless
4.8/5 - 1073 Reviews
Extra Space Storage, Coram, NY 11727
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- 24 hour access
5' x 5' Small $49/mo
10' x 10' Medium $187/mo
8' x 25' Large $174/mo
View Details
Clean, well maintained. They were exactly what I needed for a housing transition. Every time I went I could easily find a cart to use. The last few times there were two carts!
Pamela Abshire

Contactless
4.7/5 - 293 Reviews
Public Storage, Miller Place, NY 11764
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $74/mo
10' x 10' Medium $198/mo
10' x 20' Large $374/mo
View Details
4.3/5 - 42 Reviews
Medford Mini Storage, Medford, NY 11763
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
- Onsite Manager
Rent online
Bonnies Lodge - 123 Foster Drive, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
- Availability 24 Hours
- Elevator Access
5' x 5' Small $75/mo
4 units available Rent Now
Wow what a great place
John S

Contactless
4.9/5 - 295 Reviews
Extra Space Storage, Patchogue, NY 11772
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
4' x 5' Small $52/mo
10' x 10' Medium $191/mo
10' x 20' Large $166/mo
View Details
I went looking for a storage unit and the store manager Larry was exceptional. He showed me units, went over rates, and he got me the best price. Very friendly and personable. Would absolutely recommend. 10/10 thank you!
Christina Crauciuc

Contactless
4.8/5 - 582 Reviews
Extra Space Storage, Centereach, NY 11720
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $86/mo
10' x 10' Medium $180/mo
10' x 20' Large $335/mo
View Details
The personal they’re very pleasant and helpful.
Juan Martinez

Contactless
4.9/5 - 609 Reviews
Public Storage, Patchogue, NY 11772
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $70/mo
10' x 10' Medium $164/mo
10' x 20' Large $310/mo
View Details
Sam is always a pleasure & clean property !
Jean

Contactless
4.7/5 - 374 Reviews
Public Storage, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $53/mo
8' x 15' Medium $117/mo
10' x 20' Large $454/mo
View Details
Alex was the best . thank you for all your help
ANDREA BATTISTA

Contactless
4.7/5 - 320 Reviews
Public Storage, Farmingville, NY 11738
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $58/mo
9' x 15' Medium $114/mo
10' x 20' Large $276/mo
View Details
Tina is flipping amazing. I needed a larger unit than I already had. Tina went out of her way to give up her own personal unit for me. One that would fit my current needs perfectly. I cannot express my gratitude enough to Tina for going out of her way to make a space for me. She needs a raise/bonus just for her kindness and willingness to go above and beyond to help someone out. I am truly forever grateful.
susan mcsweeney

Contactless
4.4/5 - 74 Reviews
Lock Up Self Storage, The, East Setauket, NY 11733
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $47/mo
10' x 10' Medium $162/mo
10' x 20' Large $183/mo
View Details
The staff is always friendly when l stop by the office to gather my packages.
John Schaffer

Contactless
4.5/5 - 115 Reviews
Storage Post, East Setauket, NY 11733
- Climate-Controlled
- 24 hour access
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $63/mo
10' x 10' Medium $255/mo
10' x 20' Large $99/mo
View Details
Switched from Middle Island to farmingville due to very kind manager that was highly recommended Renato. Friendly and went above and beyond to make sure I got the best space for me. 5 Star service and friendliness.
Jeanine Wire-Biot

Contactless
4.9/5 - 464 Reviews
Extra Space Storage, Farmingville, NY 11738
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 4' Small $76/mo
10' x 10' Medium $205/mo
10' x 20' Large $352/mo
View Details
Fantastic! Exceptional!
ontopofthings87
No Photo Available Contactless
5/5 - 47 Reviews
Prime Storage, Centereach, NY 11720
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $80/mo
10' x 10' Medium $250/mo
10' x 20' Large $320/mo
View Details
Update they had a representative call me to investigate and make right a concern I posted. Thanks for watching out.
JoAnn Black

Contactless
4.7/5 - 150 Reviews
Public Storage, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
5' x 5' Small $58/mo
10' x 10' Medium $147/mo
11' x 30' Large $160/mo
View Details

Storage units in nearby cities:

Coram, NY : 47 storage units (3 miles away) from $49
Miller Place, NY : 7 storage units (4 miles away) from $74
Yaphank, NY : 28 storage units (5 miles away) from $65
Medford, NY : 20 storage units (5 miles away) from $57
Farmingville, NY : 42 storage units (6 miles away) from $58
Centereach, NY : 43 storage units (7 miles away) from $80
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY : 18 storage units (9 miles away) from $53
Patchogue, NY : 67 storage units (9 miles away) from $52
Holbrook, NY : 14 storage units (9 miles away) from $55
Moriches, NY : 6 storage units (11 miles away) from $29
Bayport, NY : 15 storage units (12 miles away) from $66
St James, NY : 15 storage units (12 miles away) from $59
Bohemia, NY : 60 storage units (13 miles away) from $19
Oakdale, NY : 12 storage units (14 miles away) from $58
Riverside, NY : 33 storage units (15 miles away) from $60
Kings Park, NY : 28 storage units (16 miles away) from $66
Riverhead, NY : 92 storage units (17 miles away) from $58
Brentwood, NY : 21 storage units (18 miles away) from $50
Commack, NY : 10 storage units (18 miles away) from $58
East Northport, NY : 23 storage units (20 miles away) from $66

Browse storage units in other top cities across New York:

New York City, NY : 4,991 storage units from $7
Brooklyn, NY : 1,550 storage units from $7
Queens, NY : 1,124 storage units from $10
Manhattan, NY : 687 storage units from $15
Bronx, NY : 1,219 storage units from $7
Staten Island, NY : 411 storage units from $9
Buffalo, NY : 129 storage units from $29
Yonkers, NY : 351 storage units from $17
Rochester, NY : 124 storage units from $40
Syracuse, NY : 140 storage units from $33

Browse storage units in all New York cities.

How to find the cheapest storage in Middle Island?

When looking for cheap storage units in Middle Island, timing can make a big difference. Middle Island storage prices tend to be lowest in February, averaging around $148. In contrast, November is typically the most expensive time for self storage in Middle Island, with rates reaching up to $170.

Price & Availability Index for Middle Island Storage Units

Click any point to view month-specific storage unit prices and availability at local facilities.

Monthly storage unit street rates in Middle Island
Month	Units	Average price
Aug 2025	124	$166
Sep 2025	124	$166
Oct 2025	124	$162
Nov 2025	124	$170
Dec 2025	124	$170
Jan 2026	124	$166
Feb 2026	124	$148
Mar 2026	125	$149
Apr 2026	125	$156
May 2026	125	$157
Jun 2026	125	$148
Jul 2026	125	$152

The chart above offers a clear month-by-month look at Middle Island storage rental prices, helping you see exactly when it's cheapest to book a unit. By planning and renting during the low-demand months, you'll increase your chances of locking in the best deal on storage.

What types of specialized storage can you rent in Middle Island?

Middle Island offers a variety of specialized storage options designed for vehicles and recreational equipment. Whether you need a secure spot for your car, RV, or boat, local facilities provide outdoor, covered, and indoor climate-controlled spaces to keep your investment protected year-round.

RV Storage Average price $382/mo

Car Storage Average price $240/mo

Car Storage

Car storage in Middle Island offers a safe, convenient way to keep vehicles off your driveway when not in use. Choose between outdoor (open or covered) and indoor storage. Unit sizes typically range from 10’x15’ for compact cars to 10’x30’ for larger trucks, with rates averaging around $240 per month.

RV Storage

With RV storage in Middle Island, you can park your motorhomes and trailers securely between trips. Facilities offer options from outdoor parking to fully enclosed, climate-controlled units. Prices average around $382 per month, but can vary based on size, amenities, and proximity to highways or lakes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does self storage cost in Middle Island?

On average, a Middle Island storage unit costs around $163/month. Prices vary by unit size, amenities, and neighborhood. A non-climate-controlled unit typically costs around $176/month, while a climate-controlled unit averages about $146/month.

What is the cheapest storage unit price in Middle Island right now?

The lowest storage prices in Middle Island start at $80/month for a 5′×5′ self storage unit — perfect for renters seeking budget-friendly options.

When can I find the cheapest storage units in Middle Island?

The cheapest month to rent storage in Middle Island is February, when average rates drop to around $148/month. Booking during this time can help you save more.

How do climate-controlled storage prices compare to standard units?

In Middle Island, climate-controlled storage can actually be cheaper than standard units, with average rates about 10% lower. This makes them a smart choice for protecting items from heat and humidity at a lower cost.

Storage Type

Storage Size

Price