Skip to main content
Please provide a location to search for
Near Me

Storage Type

Storage Size

Size Guide

Price

$
-
$
Unit Features
Property Features
Access
Payment & Reservations
Moving Amenities

Storage units in Bay Shore, NY, and nearby areas

305 available units | 20 facilities

See Local Prices by Unit Size

Popular storage types in Bay Shore:

Storage units in nearby cities:

Browse storage units in other top cities across New York:

Browse storage units in all New York cities.

How much is a storage unit in Bay Shore?

The average price for a storage unit in Bay Shore, NY is about $166 per month. Rates vary depending on unit size, amenities, and location.

Smaller units typically cost less, while larger, climate-controlled, or specialty units tend to command a premium.

Average Storage Unit Prices (October 2026)

Unit SizeNon-Climate ControlledClimate ControlledAll Unit Types (Average)
5x5$104$80$86
5x10$172$134$145
10x10$228$260$250
10x15$380$298$318
10x20$422$374$390
10x30$574$466$502
Average (All Sizes)$313$269$282
*Average monthly rates for Bay Shore, NY, in October 2026

How to find the cheapest storage in Bay Shore?

When looking for cheap storage units in Bay Shore, timing can make a big difference. Bay Shore storage prices tend to be lowest in March, averaging around $175. In contrast, June is typically the most expensive time for self storage in Bay Shore, with rates reaching up to $184.

Price & Availability Index for Bay Shore Storage Units

Click any point to view month-specific storage unit prices and availability at local facilities.

Monthly storage unit street rates in Bay Shore
MonthUnitsAverage price
Aug 2025326$178
Sep 2025326$179
Oct 2025326$179
Nov 2025326$180
Dec 2025327$179
Jan 2026327$177
Feb 2026328$177
Mar 2026328$175
Apr 2026328$176
May 2026329$180
Jun 2026330$184
Jul 2026330$181

The chart above offers a clear month-by-month look at Bay Shore storage rental prices, helping you see exactly when it's cheapest to book a unit. By planning and renting during the low-demand months, you'll increase your chances of locking in the best deal on storage.

These seasonal shifts in self storage costs in Bay Shore are closely tied to moving trends. Summer is peak moving season, which drives demand - and prices - higher. If you want to secure the most affordable storage in Bay Shore, consider renting during the off-season when demand drops and availability improves.

What types of specialized storage can you rent in Bay Shore?

Bay Shore offers a variety of specialized storage options designed for vehicles and recreational equipment. Whether you need a secure spot for your car, RV, or boat, local facilities provide outdoor, covered, and indoor climate-controlled spaces to keep your investment protected year-round.

RV Storage Average price $299/mo
Car Storage Average price $197/mo
Boat Storage Average price $342/mo

Car Storage

Car storage in Bay Shore offers a safe, convenient way to keep vehicles off your driveway when not in use. Choose between outdoor (open or covered) and indoor storage. Unit sizes typically range from 10’x15’ for compact cars to 10’x30’ for larger trucks, with rates averaging around $197 per month.

RV Storage

With RV storage in Bay Shore, you can park your motorhomes and trailers securely between trips. Facilities offer options from outdoor parking to fully enclosed, climate-controlled units. Prices average around $299 per month, but can vary based on size, amenities, and proximity to highways or lakes.

Boat Storage

Boat storage in Bay Shore provides an ideal off-season home for your watercraft. You can choose between outdoor and indoor climate-controlled storage options. Unit sizes range from 10x20 to 10x30, with average rents around $342 per month, depending on location and features.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does self storage cost in Bay Shore?

On average, a Bay Shore storage unit costs around $166/month. Prices vary by unit size, amenities, and neighborhood. A non-climate-controlled unit typically costs around $145/month, while a climate-controlled unit averages about $160/month.

The lowest storage prices in Bay Shore start at $30/month for a 5′×5′ self storage unit — perfect for renters seeking budget-friendly options.

The cheapest month to rent storage in Bay Shore is March, when average rates drop to around $175/month. Booking during this time can help you save more.

In Bay Shore, climate-controlled storage can actually be cheaper than standard units, with average rates about 4% lower. This makes them a smart choice for protecting items from heat and humidity at a lower cost.

Yes, some storage facilities in Bay Shore offer 24/7 access so you can reach your unit anytime. Before renting, check the facility's business hours or access policy to ensure it matches your schedule. Round-the-clock access is ideal if you need flexibility or plan to visit your unit outside standard hours.

Based on 1,274 reviews, storage customers in Bay Shore rated their experience an impressive 4.7. This excellent score highlights consistently strong satisfaction with Bay Shore storage facilities, from customer service to overall convenience.