Car storage units in Middle Island, NY, and nearby areas

Q: What size storage unit is best for a car?

A 10’&#215;20’ unit is the go-to size for most standard cars. Compact cars? You might only need a 10’&#215;15’. Trucks, vans, or larger SUVs? A 10’&#215;30’ will give you the extra space you need.

Q: Can two cars fit in a 10&#215;30 storage unit?

Yes – in most cases! A 10’&#215;30’ unit is about the size of a standard two-car garage, so you can usually fit two compact vehicles side by side.

272 available units | 11 facilities

I am writing to share a wonderful experience at Extra Space Storage with Dennis Brunner and Anthony. Dennis took the time to explain everything to me and patiently answered all of my questions. Moving is a very stressful time- after speaking with Dennis- I am grateful for his genuine kindness and professionalism. I highly recommend their services.
Heidi Fischer
Contactless
4.9/5 - 590 Reviews
Extra Space Storage - 901 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY 11953
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
10x20 Large $323/mo
Daniel was extremely helpful and pleasant to deal with
Nola Thacker
4.9/5 - 866 Reviews
Extra Space Storage - 14 Francis Mooney Drive, Ridge, NY 11961
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
8x25 Large $105/mo
Great people here! Very helpful!
colton fusaro

Contactless
4.8/5 - 1044 Reviews
Extra Space Storage - 2025 Route 112, Coram, NY 11727
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- 24 hour access
8x25 Large $206/mo
10/10 will rent from riss again. Wonderful human.
Mike Scala

Contactless
4.7/5 - 339 Reviews
Public Storage - 544 Middle Country Road, Coram, NY 11727
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
8x15 Medium $114/mo
Great staff at the unit in yaphank. They answered all my questions. I was signing up online and a staff member called me during the process to see if I had any other questions. I was able to sign up easily online. I was oriented to the facility when I arrived and shown how to use the lock they provided. It is clean and appears to be very safe. They have cameras all over the place to make sure your belongings are safe. Overall a great experience. Facility was clean and organized. Staff is friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. Don't hesitate just book it!!!
Christine Labanowski

Contactless
4.9/5 - 718 Reviews
Devon Self Storage - 84 Long Island Avenue, Yaphank, NY 11980
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
12x20 Large $140/mo
How much space do you need?
Use our calculator to quickly find the right unit size for your belongings.
Find My Unit Size
I moved in seven months ago in between houses and Alex was helpful every step of every step of the way. Would highly recommend.
Scott Schneider

Contactless
4.7/5 - 329 Reviews
Public Storage - 508 Route 25A, Mount Sinai, NY 11766
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
10x20 Large $368/mo
The gentleman who was there yesterday morning was SUPER helpful! He deserves a raise.
Bill Gonzalez

Contactless
4.8/5 - 317 Reviews
Public Storage - 951 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
10x20 Large $295/mo
Very friendly and helpful throughout the process!
Anna Vertypolokh

Contactless
4.8/5 - 573 Reviews
Extra Space Storage - 2626 Middle Country Road, Centereach, NY 11720
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
10x20 Large $371/mo
Leslie was very professional and helpful when I went to the Patchogue store. Highly recommended
Mary Ramos

Contactless
4.9/5 - 291 Reviews
Extra Space Storage - 500 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue, NY 11772
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
10x20 Large $196/mo
Este store check esta muy bueno n Renato que es el manager es muy buenas persona y los puede ayudar
Martin Hernandez

Contactless
4.9/5 - 422 Reviews
Extra Space Storage - 1027 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
10x20 Large $231/mo
Friendly and responsive staff. Easy to work with and a good price.
Reyes Cortes

Contactless
4.8/5 - 596 Reviews
Public Storage - 601 West Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue, NY 11772
- Climate-Controlled
- Indoor
- Drive-Up Access
8x20 Medium $117/mo
10x20 Large $320/mo

Popular storage types in Middle Island:

Self storage from $9

Car storage units in nearby cities:

Coram, NY : 4 storage units (3 miles away) from $30
Yaphank, NY : 1 storage unit (5 miles away) from $62
Farmingville, NY : 3 storage units (6 miles away) from $57
Centereach, NY : 1 storage unit (7 miles away) from $88
Patchogue, NY : 3 storage units (9 miles away) from $57
Holbrook, NY : 1 storage unit (9 miles away) from $60
Bohemia, NY : 3 storage units (13 miles away) from $9
Oakdale, NY : 2 storage units (14 miles away) from $50
Riverside, NY : 1 storage unit (15 miles away) from $84
Kings Park, NY : 2 storage units (16 miles away) from $79
Riverhead, NY : 2 storage units (17 miles away) from $67
Brentwood, NY : 3 storage units (18 miles away) from $49
Commack, NY : 1 storage unit (18 miles away) from $42
East Northport, NY : 2 storage units (20 miles away) from $59
Bay Shore, NY : 4 storage units (20 miles away) from $10
Northport, NY : 1 storage unit (20 miles away) from $65

Browse storage units in other top cities across New York:

New York City, NY : 4,885 storage units from $7
Brooklyn, NY : 1,403 storage units from $7
Queens, NY : 1,139 storage units from $10
Manhattan, NY : 720 storage units from $21
Bronx, NY : 1,162 storage units from $7
Staten Island, NY : 461 storage units from $9
Buffalo, NY : 98 storage units from $48
Yonkers, NY : 146 storage units from $20
Rochester, NY : 129 storage units from $56
Syracuse, NY : 123 storage units from $50

Browse storage units in all New York cities.

Car storage cost

If you’re looking to store your car in Middle Island, NY, you can expect to pay around $241 per month. That’s 49% more than the national average of $162.

💡

Why the price might be higher: In Middle Island, NY, high demand and limited space mean that good car storage gets snapped up quickly. When you find a solid rate, it's a smart move to lock it in.

How much does car storage cost in Middle Island, NY?

Avg. Car Storage Rent

$241/mo

National Avg. Car Storage Rent

$162/mo

Data from StorageCafe, July 2026

Not sure what size you need? Let’s find out.

Find the right unit size for your vehicle. Choose your make, model, and year to see what fits best.

Car storage options

Finding the right place to store your car in Middle Island, NY is simple. With 1 local facility offering a range of choices, you can pick what works best for your vehicle and budget – whether that’s a basic outdoor space or an indoor unit with full protection.

Outdoor car storage: affordable and convenient, great for everyday vehicles and short-term needs.

Open outdoor storage

Budget-friendly option on paved, gravel, or grass surfaces
Best for warm-weather or short-term storage
Tip: Use a quality car cover for extra protection

Covered outdoor storage

Still outdoors, but under a canopy or carport
Extra protection from sun and rain
Great balance between cost and coverage

Indoor car storage: Best for long-term protection or storing classic/luxury vehicles.

Park inside a garage-style unit or shared indoor space
Shields your car from rain, snow, and temperature swings
Some units offer climate control for added protection against humidity
Ideal for classic cars, convertibles, or off-season vehicles

Frequently Asked Questions

What size storage unit is best for a car?

A 10’×20’ unit is the go-to size for most standard cars. Compact cars? You might only need a 10’×15’. Trucks, vans, or larger SUVs? A 10’×30’ will give you the extra space you need.

Can two cars fit in a 10×30 storage unit?

Yes – in most cases! A 10’×30’ unit is about the size of a standard two-car garage, so you can usually fit two compact vehicles side by side.

Can I store a classic car in a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

Absolutely. For a classic, luxury, or collector car, your best bet is a climate-controlled indoor unit. This keeps temperature and humidity stable, helping preserve your vehicle’s finish and components.

How to find storage near me

Looking for the best storage options in Columbus, OH? We've got you covered with the most extensive inventory of listings, conveniently available online. Use our location finder to search for storage space in your desired area and easily compare features, prices and unit sizes to find the perfect spot for all your stuff.

Ready to find the perfect storage solution in Columbus? Find Storage Near Me

Storage Type

Storage Size

Price